La Muse
Robert Parker Wine Advocate
- 1998 vintage: 95 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 1999 vintage: 97 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2000 vintage: 91 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2001 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2002 vintage: 99 points, Robert Parker, June 2012
- 2003 vintage: 95 points, Robert Parker, June 2013
- 2004 vintage: 98 points, Robert Parker, April 2014
- 2005 vintage: 98 points, Robert Parker, June 2015
- 2006 vintage: 92 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2007 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2008 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2009 vintage: 96+ points, Robert Parker, December 2013
- 2010 vintage: 94 points, Robert Parker, December 2013
- 2011 vintage: 91 points, Robert Parker, December 2014
- 2012 vintage: 97 points, Robert Parker, October 2015
- 2013 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, October 2015
- 2014 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, October 2016
- 2015 vintage: 97 points, Lisa Perrotti-Brown, February 2018
- 2016 vintage: 100 points, Lisa Perrotti-Brown, October 2018
- 2017 vintage: 99 points, Lisa Perrotti-Brown, May 2020
Vinous
- 1998 vintage: 90 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2001
- 1999 vintage: 93 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2019
- 2000 vintage: 91 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2003
- 2001 vintage: 92 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2004
- 2002 vintage: 92 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2005
- 2003 vintage: 93 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2006
- 2004 vintage: 95+ points, Stephen Tanzer, June 2015
- 2005 vintage: 94 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2016
- 2006 vintage: 93 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2009
- 2007 vintage: 95 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2017
- 2008 vintage: 93+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2012
- 2009 vintage: 95 points, Stephen Tanzer, July 2019
- 2010 vintage: 97 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2020
- 2011 vintage: 92 points, Antonio Galloni, January 2015
- 2012 vintage: 94 points, Antonio Galloni, February 2016
- 2014 vintage: 96 points, Antonio Galloni, March 2017
- 2016 vintage: 94 points, Antonio Galloni, April 2020
- 2017 vintage: 96 points, Antonio Galloni, April 2020
Wine Spectator
- 2000 vintage: 91 points, James Laube, August 2004
- 2008 vintage: 91 points, James Laube, November 2012
- 2016 vintage: 92 points, Kim Marcus, July 2019
Wine Enthusiast
- 2006 vintage: 94 points, Steve Heimoff, May 2011
- 2007 vintage: 100 points, Steve Heimoff, July 2012
- 2008 vintage: 93 points, Steve Heimoff, July 2012
Jeb Dunnuck
- 2002 vintage: 98 points, Jeb Dunnuck, June 2019
- 2011 vintage: 94 points, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2021
- 2014 vintage: 97+ points, Jeb Dunnuck, January 2017
- 2016 vintage: 100 points, Jeb Dunnuck, June 2019
- 2017 vintage: 98 points, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2020
- 2018 vintage: 94 points, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2021
JamesSuckling.com
- 2002 vintage: 93 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2005 vintage: 98 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2013 vintage: 98 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2014 vintage: 94 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2015 vintage: 97 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2016 vintage: 96 points, James Suckling, May 2019
- 2017 vintage: 98 points, James Suckling, May 2020
- 2018 vintage: 98 points, James Suckling, March 2021
Anthony Gismondi On Wine
- 2013 vintage: 97 points, Anthony Gismondi and Treve Ring, January 2018
La Revue du Vin de France
- 2012 vintage: 19/20 points, Pierre Vila Palleja, April 2018
Jancis Robinson
- 2014 vintage: 17/20 points, Richard Hemming MW, November 2017
La Joie
Robert Parker Wine Advocate
- 1998 vintage: 94 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 1999 vintage: 95 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2000 vintage: 89 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2001 vintage: 95+ points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2002 vintage: 98 points, Robert Parker, June 2012
- 2003 vintage: 95+ points, Robert Parker, June 2013
- 2004 vintage: 99 points, Robert Parker, April 2014
- 2005 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, June 2015
- 2006 vintage: 92 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2007 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2008 vintage: 99 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2009 vintage: 96 points, Robert Parker, December 2013
- 2010 vintage: 92+ points, Robert Parker, December 2013
- 2011 vintage: 90 points, Robert Parker, December 2014
- 2012 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, October 2015
- 2013 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, October 2015
- 2014 vintage: 97+ points, Robert Parker, October 2016
- 2015 vintage: 99 points, Lisa Perrotti-Brown, February 2018
- 2016 vintage: 98 points, Lisa Perrotti-Brown, October 2018
- 2017 vintage: 98+ points, Lisa Perrotti-Brown, May 2020
Vinous
- 1998 vintage: 90+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2001
- 1999 vintage: 92 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2019
- 2000 vintage: 90+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2003
- 2001 vintage: 93 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2004
- 2002 vintage: 94 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2005
- 2003 vintage: 94+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2006
- 2004 vintage: 96+ points, Stephen Tanzer, June 2015
- 2005 vintage: 95+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2016
- 2006 vintage: 96 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2009
- 2007 vintage: 93+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2017
- 2008 vintage: 94+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2012
- 2009 vintage: 95+ points, Stephen Tanzer, July 2019
- 2010 vintage: 93 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2020
- 2011 vintage: 93 points, Antonio Galloni, January 2015
- 2012 vintage: 94 points, Antonio Galloni, February 2016
- 2014 vintage: 97+ points, Antonio Galloni, March 2017
- 2016 vintage: 97 points, Antonio Galloni, April 2020
- 2017 vintage: 96 points, Antonio Galloni, April 2020
Wine Spectator
- 2012 vintage: 91 points, James Laube, October 2015
Wine Enthusiast
- 2006 vintage: 98 points, Steve Heimoff, May 2011
- 2007 vintage: 96 points, Steve Heimoff, July 2012
- 2008 vintage: 94 points, Steve Heimoff, July 2012
Jeb Dunnuck
- 1998 vintage: 94 points, Jeb Dunnuck, June 2019
- 2005 vintage: 100 points, Jeb Dunnuck, June 2019
- 2011 vintage: 96 points, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2021
- 2014 vintage: 97+ points, Jeb Dunnuck, January 2017
- 2016 vintage: 100 points, Jeb Dunnuck, June 2019
- 2017 vintage: 98 points, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2020
- 2018 vintage: 96 points, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2021
JamesSuckling.com
- 1998 vintage: 91 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2005 vintage: 94 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2013 vintage: 99 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2014 vintage: 96 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2015 vintage: 97 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2016 vintage: 97 points, James Suckling, May 2019
- 2017 vintage: 98 points, James Suckling, April 2020
- 2018 vintage: 99 points, James Suckling, March 2021
Anthony Gismondi On Wine
- 2013 vintage: 97 points, Anthony Gismondi, October 2017
La Revue du Vin de France
- 2012 vintage: 19.5/20 points, Pierre Vila Palleja, April 2018
Decanter
- 1998 vintage: 97 points, Jane Anson, October 2018
- 2011 vintage: 95 points, Matthew Luczy, February 2021
- 2013 vintage: 95 points, William Kelly, August 2016
- 2015 vintage: 98 points, Jane Anson, October 2018
Jancis Robinson
- 2009 vintage: 17/20 points, Jancis Robinson, December 2017
- 2014 vintage: 16.5/20 points, Richard Hemming MW, March 2018
Le Désir
Robert Parker Wine Advocate
- 2000 vintage: 90 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2001 vintage: 97 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2002 vintage: 93 points, Robert Parker, June 2012
- 2003 vintage: 99 points, Robert Parker, June 2013
- 2004 vintage: 98 points, Robert Parker, April 2014
- 2005 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, June 2015
- 2006 vintage: 90 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2007 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2008 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, May 2011
- 2009 vintage: 93 points, Robert Parker, December 2013
- 2010 vintage: 93 points, Robert Parker, December 2013
- 2011 vintage: 92 points, Robert Parker, December 2014
- 2012 vintage: 100 points, Robert Parker, October 2015
- 2013 vintage: 99 points, Robert Parker, October 2015
- 2014 vintage: 98 points, Robert Parker, October 2016
- 2015 vintage: 100 points, Lisa Perrotti-Brown, February 2018
- 2016 vintage: 99 points, Lisa Perrotti-Brown, October 2018
- 2017 vintage: 98 points, Lisa Perrotti-Brown, May 2020
Vinous
- 2000 vintage: 92 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2003
- 2001 vintage: 93+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2004
- 2002 vintage: 93+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2005
- 2003 vintage: 93+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2006
- 2004 vintage: 94+ points, Stephen Tanzer, June 2015
- 2005 vintage: 91 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2016
- 2006 vintage: 94+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2009
- 2007 vintage: 94+ points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2017
- 2008 vintage: 96 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2012
- 2009 vintage: 91 points, Stephen Tanzer, July 2019
- 2010 vintage: 96 points, Stephen Tanzer, May 2020
- 2011 vintage: 93 points, Antonio Galloni, January 2015
- 2012 vintage: 95 points, Antonio Galloni, March 2016
- 2014 vintage: 97 points, Antonio Galloni, March 2017
- 2016 vintage: 98 points, Antonio Galloni, April 2020
- 2017 vintage: 98 points, Antonio Galloni, April 2020
Wine Spectator
- 2008 vintage: 90 points, James Laube, November 2012
Wine Enthusiast
- 2006 vintage: 95 points, Steve Heimoff, May 2011
- 2007 vintage: 97 points, Steve Heimoff, July 2012
- 2008 vintage: 97 points, Steve Heimoff, July 2012
Jeb Dunnuck
- 2009 vintage: 97 points, Jeb Dunnuck, June 2019
- 2011 vintage: 94 points, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2021
- 2014 vintage: 99 points, Jeb Dunnuck, December 2017
- 2016 vintage: 99 points, Jeb Dunnuck, June 2019
- 2017 vintage: 98+ points, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2020
- 2018 vintage: 94 points, Jeb Dunnuck, May 2021
JamesSuckling.com
- 2005 vintage: 91 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2013 vintage: 93 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2014 vintage: 97 points, James Suckling, November 2018
- 2015 vintage: 98 points, James Suckling, December 2018
- 2016 vintage: 96 points, James Suckling, May 2019
- 2017 vintage: 98 points, James Suckling, May 2020
- 2018 vintage: 97 points, James Suckling, March 2021
La Revue du Vin de France
- 2005 vintage: 20/20 points, Pierre Vila Palleja, April 2018
- 2012 vintage: 19.5/20 points, Pierre Vila Palleja, April 2018
- 2013 vintage: 96 points, Anthony Gismondi, October 2017
Decanter
- 2013 vintage: 96 points, William Kelly, April 2017
- 2014 vintage: 95 points, William Kelly, September 2017
Jancis Robinson
- 2014 vintage: 17/20 points, Jancis Robinson, November 2017